Excerpt, from (in my opinion) a pretty good post:
"Oddly enough, most of the 'social media experts' that write books on the subject (read: get paid to speak, not to actually have ever managed social media for a client) tend to spend most of their tweets sharing quotes and news stories. The celebrities are split into two groups: ones that say really mundane things that we adore like reading People Magazine and the ones that attempt to use it as a platform for social change (yet don't follow anyone back.) Most of the companies on Twitter are talking at you in a way that is basically an advertising bastardization of this social tool. The 'professionals' seem to think that passing along news articles all day long is the sole use of Twitter – and sadly most of them are about 3 hour behind everyone else. The MLM crowds spam you constantly and create one or two fake 'real tweets' between spam to fool people. (Who? I'm not sure.)..."
(Amanda Vega Consulting) [emphasis mine]
My guess is that "MLN" stands for Multi-Level Marketing: Not Marxism-Leninism-Maoism. I suppose it could be Mailing List Manager or Mid-Level Manager, but that doesn't seem too likely. The lesson there is, I think: beware acronyms. You know what you mean, but others may not.
There's more - quite a lot more - in the original post.
The advice - to view (alleged) experts skeptically - is, I think, valid. You'd think that publishing houses wouldn't waste ink, paper, and marketing resources on an inaccurate book: but the fact is that many are more interested in turning a profit, than being helpful. My opinion. And, some editor - or, worse, manager - may think that the wannabe expert is the hottest thing since
Aaron Montgomery Ward decided to mail a catalog to prospects. (Why 'or worse'? Managers can do more damage to their companies than editors. My opinion.)
I think the author was on the right track, characterizing online communities as being "
...like an electronic high school...." The point that so many marketing 'experts' seem to miss is that people in online communities are -
people. Some of us seem to have had our last contact with Homo sapiens sapiens in the mid-to-late teens, with high school as the major social experience.
Think about it.
Think about it. You're trying to convince people that they'd be interested in a product or service of yours. And, that you're in high school. Standing in the hall, or in the lunch room.
How effective would it be - in the long run - if you kept shouting things like "I made eight thousand dollars in the last eight minutes!!!!" or "Cleaner!! Meaner!! Cuts Grease!!!" - - - You get the idea.
Or, if you're an "expert," you don't.
Spelling it out: online communities are
communities. They're made up of people, not targets for marketing. If you throw advertising slogans at them, likely enough they'll tune you out - promptly, and maybe permanently.
That kind of 'marketing strategy' you don't need.
Sort-of-related posts about marketing:
- "Well, That's Interesting: Web Strategy Matrix: Google Buzz vs Facebook vs MySpace vs Twitter"
(February 11, 2010) - "What Not to do On Twitter (Or Any Social Media)"
Apathetic Lemming of the North (February 3, 2010) - "Well, That's Interesting: Tweetmeme and Twittley Button"
(February 2, 2010) - "A Thought for the Day: Marketing Isn't Yucky"
(September 19, 2009) - "FTC and Bogus Blog Endorsements: Sounds Sensible"
(April 3, 2009) - "Annoying Your Website's Visitors: Not as Good an Idea as it Seems"
(February 4, 2009) - "Marketing Your Blog: Linkbaiting Advice"
(January 1, 2009) - "How Not to Close a Business"
(April 30, 2008) - ""Banned in Boston" - Not the Worst Fate"
(April 2, 2008) - "Online Publicity and Marketing"
(August 17, 2007)
More:
A tip of the hat to
Twitter_Tips, on Twitter, for the heads-up on this post.